21 Best Pizza Places in Indianapolis: A Local Guide

Indianapolis, the capital city of Indiana, is known for many things, and one of them is its vibrant pizza scene. From classic New York-style pizzas to deep-dish masterpieces, this city has it all. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust or stuffed pizzas, Indianapolis has a pizza place that will satisfy cravings.

In this local guide, we’ll take you on a culinary journey to discover the 21 best pizza places in Indianapolis. So, get ready to indulge in some mouthwatering slices of pizza as we explore the top pizza spots in the city.

1. Pizzology

Pizzology

Renowned for its artisanal pizzas using locally sourced, premium ingredients, Pizzology offers a creative selection of toppings and flavor combinations. Expertly cooked in a wood-fired oven, their pizzas have a delightful smokiness, with a crust that strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy.

The cozy, inviting ambiance adds to the experience of enjoying delicious pizza. Pizzology is a must-visit for deep-dish and hangover pizza enthusiasts in Indianapolis.

2. Two Guys Pies

Two Guys Pies

Two Guys Pies offers an array of classic and inventive pizzas. Fresh, quality ingredients guarantee exceptional flavors with generous toppings and a well-balanced crust. The pizzeria ensures consistently flavorful and satisfying pizzas in a laid-back setting, perfect for savoring delectable creations.

Patrons can enjoy a diverse menu featuring deep dishes and hangover pizzas, enhancing the experience of savoring each slice.

3. Ale Emporium

Ale Emporium

Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Ale Emporium presents a tantalizing array of specialty pizzas, perfectly paired with an impressive selection of craft beers. Each pizza is renowned for its abundant toppings and adventurous flavors, promising a delightful culinary experience.

The vibrant and relaxed ambiance at Ale Emporium offers the ideal setting to savor these delectable pizzas. Notably, the crust strikes an impeccable balance between crispy and tender, elevating the overall pizza indulgence. This establishment undoubtedly serves as a fantastic venue for gathering with friends and relishing exceptional pizza.

4. Bob’s Tu Your Door Pizza

Bob’s Tu Your Door Pizza

Celebrated for their fresh, flavorful pizzas crafted with quality ingredients, Bob’s Tu Your Door Pizza offers a wide variety of toppings and pizza styles. Patrons can rely on prompt delivery service and savor the perfect texture and flavor of the crust. The pizzeria fosters a warm and inviting atmosphere for enjoying these delectable pizzas.

5. LaSpada’s Pizzeria

LaSpada’s Pizzeria

LaSpada’s Pizzeria creates authentic Italian-style pizzas with a delightful blend of fresh ingredients, offering a cozy, family-friendly environment. The renowned crust strikes the perfect balance between crispiness and chewiness, allowing patrons to savor genuine Italian flavors.

6. Frank’s Place

Frank’s Place

Acclaimed for its indulgent deep dish creations, Frank’s Place offers a diverse menu catering to all pizza preferences. Ensuring consistently flavorful options, the pizzeria’s perfect crust texture is a crowd-pleaser. Patrons revel in the cozy atmosphere, savoring hangover pizzas and signature selections.

From Pearl Street Pizzeria to chain pizza lovers, this gem at Broad Ripple stands out among pizza restaurants in Indy, Indiana. With influences from Chicago to Detroit, Frank’s Place delivers a delightful pizza experience that satisfies every time.

7. Puccini’s Pizza & Pasta

Puccini’s Pizza & Pasta

Renowned for its handcrafted pizzas and pasta, Puccini’s Pizza & Pasta prioritizes high-quality, fresh ingredients for exceptional flavors. The vibrant ambiance invites pizza enthusiasts to savor the perfect balance of the delightful crust.

Patrons experience an authentic Italian dining atmosphere, making it a go-to destination for deep dishes and hangover pizzas in Indianapolis. Located in Broad Ripple, Puccini’s is a must-visit for food trucks, chain pizza, and burger aficionados, adding to the diverse pizza restaurants in Indy.

8. Hilltop Tavern

Hilltop Tavern

Nestled in a cozy atmosphere, Hilltop Tavern offers a diverse range of pizza options, including gluten-free and vegan choices. Their pizza is renowned for its unique toppings and mouthwatering flavor combinations, appealing to all tastes.

Patrons can savor the casual dining experience with family or friends while enjoying outdoor seating. The menu features both classic and inventive options, making it a perfect spot for those craving variety in their pizza selection.

9. King Dough Pizza

King Dough Pizza

King Dough Pizza provides a distinct pizza experience with its Neapolitan-style, wood-fired pizzas. The pizzeria prioritizes premium organic ingredients for pizza preparation and ferments their dough naturally for over 72 hours, resulting in a richly flavored crust. Additionally, King Dough Pizza caters to dietary preferences by offering a diverse range of vegan and gluten-free pizza options. Customers can also indulge in craft beer and cocktails while savoring their pizzas.

10. MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub

MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub

Featuring a diverse menu of gourmet pizzas and pub fare, MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub offers a unique dining experience. With unique toppings like bison, elk, and huckleberries, the restaurant stands out.

Customers can enjoy a relaxed atmosphere with outdoor seating and choose from a wide selection of craft beers and cocktails to complement their pizzas. Known for its family-friendly ambiance, MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable dining experience.

11. Magoo’s California Pizza

Magoo’s California Pizza

At Magoo’s California Pizza, patrons can indulge in a diverse range of specialty pizzas, including their renowned deep-dish option. The pizzeria is celebrated for its abundant toppings and delectable pizza sauces, ensuring a flavorsome experience with each bite.

Guests can relish a laid-back dining atmosphere while savoring exceptional pizzas and delightful cocktails. Additionally, Magoo’s California Pizza boasts an extensive beer selection to complement its offerings and also facilitates takeout and delivery services for added convenience.

12. Vito Provolone’s Restaurant

Vito Provolone’s Restaurant

At Vito Provolone’s Restaurant, indulge in authentic Italian pizzas, from classic thin crust to indulgent stuffed options. The cozy ambiance is ideal for family gatherings and special occasions. Choose from traditional toppings such as Italian sausage, pepperoni, and fresh veggies.

The diverse menu also includes pasta dishes, calzones, and savory chicken wings. Experience exceptional service in a warm and inviting setting that’s perfect for savoring deep dishes and hangover pizzas. This pizzeria in Indianapolis is a must-visit for a taste of classic Italian flavors.

13. Panoony’s

Panoony’s

Panoony’s, a beloved pizza destination, is famous for its New York-style pizzas and welcoming service. With a wide array of pizza toppings and specialty pizzas, it caters to diverse preferences. Customers relish a relaxed dining experience with delectable pizza and fantastic cocktails.

Known for serving some of the finest pizza in Indianapolis, it attracts locals and visitors alike. The pizzeria offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere, cementing its status as a top pizza spot in the city.

14. Richard’s Brick Oven Pizza

Richard’s Brick Oven Pizza

Serving up authentic, brick-oven pizzas with a thin crust and fresh, flavorful toppings, Richard’s Brick Oven Pizza offers a cozy, inviting ambiance suitable for intimate gatherings or casual dining. Customers can indulge in high-quality cheese, olive oil, and premium ingredients, ensuring a real-deal pizza experience. The pizzeria is a great place to enjoy delicious pizzas and good company, while the attentive staff guarantees a pleasant dining experience.

15. St. Louis

St. Louis

With its distinctive, cracker-thin crust pizzas and signature toppings, St. Louis offers a unique take on pizza. The pizzeria prides itself on using fresh, local ingredients to create flavorful and memorable pizzas, providing a relaxed, casual atmosphere for customers to indulge in top-quality pizzas.

In addition to its excellent pizza, St. Louis features a variety of beer selections and cocktails to complement the dining experience, making it a great place for pizza enthusiasts.

16. Sicilian

Sicilian

Nestled in the heart of downtown, Sicilian stands out for its authentic Sicilian-style pizzas, featuring a thick, airy crust and flavorful toppings. The pizzeria is known for its generous portions and bold Mediterranean-inspired flavors, offering a cozy, welcoming environment for pizza enthusiasts.

With a great selection of toppings, including Italian sausage and fresh herbs, Sicilian provides an opportunity to savor the taste of Sicily through its delectable pizzas. Whether it’s the hangover pizzas or the classic deep dish, Sicilian offers a delightful culinary journey.

17. Bazbeaux Pizza

Bazbeaux Pizza

Celebrated for its artisanal toppings and flavor combinations, Bazbeaux Pizza offers gourmet pizzas in a vibrant, eclectic atmosphere, perfect for pizza enthusiasts. Customers can savor unique, inventive pizza creations made with fresh, quality ingredients. The pizzeria also features a great selection of beer and wine to enhance the pizza enjoyment experience, making it a great place for enjoying innovative pizzas and a vibrant dining ambiance.

18. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza takes pride in its mouthwatering, thin-crust pizzas teeming with locally sourced toppings. This vibrant pizzeria offers a convivial ambiance, perfect for relishing delectable pizza creations with loved ones.

Patrons can savor an extensive array of toppings, including unique choices like goat cheese and Greek-inspired flavors. With its charming outdoor seating, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza crafts an inviting and delightful dining experience. Renowned for its unwavering dedication to quality and innovation, this pizzeria stands as a beloved pizza haven in Indianapolis.

19. Tavern-style

Tavern-style

Tavern-style pizza, originating in the United States, features a thin crust and square-cut slices. Its unique flavor profile comes from placing the toppings under the cheese. A favorite among pizza enthusiasts, this style is known for its crispy crust and delicious toppings.

The distinct taste of tavern-style pizza has made it a popular choice, especially in areas like Indy and Chicago. The combination of crispy crust and flavorful toppings sets it apart from other pizza styles.

20. Wood-fired American

Wood-fired American

Wood-fired American pizza, cooked in a wood-fired oven, offers a unique smoky flavor and features fresh, high-quality ingredients like buffalo mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes. This style is popular among pizza lovers seeking an authentic, rustic taste, known for its thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The wood-fired cooking method creates a delightful char on the crust, adding to the rustic appeal of this delicious pizza style.

21. Stuffed

Stuffed

Indulge in the deeply satisfying experience of stuffed pizza. With its hearty, generous portions and a crust oozing with cheese and toppings, this style is perfect for those with a big appetite. Stuffed pizza aficionados appreciate its thick, indulgent crust, delivering a delightful combination of cheese, toppings, and savory sauce. The deep-dish allure of stuffed pizza will leave you craving more, making it a must-try for pizza enthusiasts.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some unique pizza toppings offered by the top pizza places in Indianapolis?

Some of the top pizza places in Indianapolis offer unique pizza toppings like macaroni and cheese, tater tots, and BBQ pulled pork. You can also find interesting options like goat cheese, figs, and bacon jam. Vegan and gluten-free choices are available too. Don’t be afraid to try something new!

Are there any pizza places that specialize in gluten-free or vegan options?

The pizza places in Indianapolis, Indianapolis has a variety of pizza places that cater to gluten-free and vegan diets. Napolese Pizzeria, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza, and Bazbeaux Pizza are popular options that offer separate menus or indicate which items are gluten-free or vegan. It’s advisable to call ahead to confirm availability.

What are some of the most popular pizza places in Indianapolis and why?

The pizza places in Indianapolis, Some of the most popular pizza places in Indianapolis include Bazbeaux Pizza, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza, and Diavola Pizza. These restaurants have earned their reputation through their fresh ingredients, unique flavor combinations, gluten-free options, Neapolitan-style crust, and authentic Italian flavors. Customers love them for their high-quality ingredients, delicious flavors, and excellent customer service.

Are there any hidden gem pizza places in Indianapolis that locals love?

The pizza places in Indianapolis, Indianapolis is home to several hidden gem pizza places that locals love. Some of these include Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza, Bazbeaux Pizza, and Brozinni Pizzeria. These spots offer unique toppings and crust options, making them a must-visit for any pizza lover. Don’t hesitate to ask locals for recommendations or embark on your pizza adventure!

Conclusion

In conclusion, the pizza places in Indianapolis, Indianapolis is a pizza lover’s paradise with a wide range of options to satisfy any craving. Whether you’re in the mood for classic flavors or adventurous toppings, this local guide has got you covered. From the wood-fired American style of Two Guys Pies to the stuffed creations at St. Louis, there’s something for everyone.

Don’t forget to try the unique offerings like the gluten-free and vegan options at Pizzology or the tavern-style pies at Hilltop Tavern. And if you’re looking for hidden gems, be sure to check out Frank’s Place or Magoo’s California Pizza. So grab a slice, snap a picture, and share your delicious journey through Indianapolis’ best pizza places on social media.

 

Related Posts:

19 Best Things to Do in South Bend, Indiana

THE 15 BEST Things to Do in Newport News

24 Top Things to Do in Kentucky

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *